A Statement on Hiring in Theoretical Computer Science

Supporting quality over quantity and depth of understanding in the post-AI era.

In early September 2026, the Simons Institute for the Theory of Computing held a working group called AI and TCS: the next six months. The goal of the workshop was to recommend actions for the community to take in the next six months to help the field adjust to the new reality. The full report is available online.

One of the recommended actions (Action 7) concerned practices around hiring in the post-AI era. The two main challenges identified are that:

  1. it has become less clear which traits to look for, and
  2. their identification based on accomplishments may become harder in the presence of AI.

These challenges obfuscate what early career researchers view as success and how their mentors should guide them. Without a conscious change to our culture and incentive structures, we may find the junior community engaged in an “arms race” in the number of research publications at the expense of quality of understanding and exposition.

We believe that one step in the right direction is to gather consensus from the senior members of our community around norms for hiring and evaluation. In an effort to signal to the young people in the community the values of quality over quantity and depth of understanding, we are seeking signatures from tenured and tenure-track faculty in support of the statement on the right.

FAQ

Why doesn’t the statement encourage departments to clearly state in their hiring calls how the use of AI will be judged?

While this was not directly addressed at the workshop and did not make it into the statement as circulated, this is clearly a need, as confirmed by numerous conversations we have since had with junior researchers. We encourage hiring committees to include a statement of values with hiring calls, clarifying their broad expectations and evaluation criteria around AI use. If it is difficult to include such language due to institutional constraints, faculty in a department may consider doing this as individuals.

Shouldn’t something like this be left to each department to decide?

Ultimately, it will be up to individual departments to decide and publicize the details of their hiring criteria. The challenge is that this takes time and departments are incentivized to do this only at the moment when they announce job opportunities. At the same time, young researchers and their mentors are seeking directional guidance now. This signing initiative is meant to both encourage departments to take up this issue as well as signal to the young people the community’s jointly held values: quality over quantity and depth of understanding.

Up to three is too rigid, or not the right number.

Three was actually chosen with care, as it is expected that the candidate’s talk and the letters will cover the work in detail. If a candidate is covering more work in their talk, it is most likely that they aren’t addressing the details with enough care.

But what about the candidate who has a body of consistent work that consists of more than three papers?

It would be perfectly fine for that candidate to make the body of work clear while selecting the three works that contained the most significant ideas/techniques.

I don’t want to publicly commit to anything.

That’s fine, but recognize that without a signal like this, young people are left without direction. In addition, the arms race of AI-assisted rushed results will continue to overwhelm the community systems in charge of trying to curate the most significant, interesting, and well-done results. Said another way: is the alternative, i.e. doing nothing, better?

This won’t age well. In a few years, we’ll be in a whole different world.

This is meant to be a short-term action. As time goes on, the community may adjust to something else.

I don’t want to be bound by this. I may want to change my mind.

You can. All you are saying is that you support this statement now. If you want to later remove your name, you can.

Adopted / Partially Adopted

UCLA Computer Science: Multiple Tenure-track Assistant Professor Positions in Computer Science (posted November 9, 2026)

In evaluating candidates, the department values a strong record of meaningful research accomplishments over the number of papers published at top conference venues. Applicants are encouraged to identify in their research statement up to three contributions they consider most significant and to explain their impact.

In addition to a research talk and one-on-one meetings, interviews include a one-hour “deep dive” session in which a small group of faculty experts asks specific questions about the candidate’s work, giving the candidate an opportunity to show the depth of their understanding.

Signatories (108)

  • Scott Aaronson University of Texas at Austin
  • Josh Alman Columbia University
  • Alex Andoni Columbia University
  • Anurag Anshu Harvard University
  • Ainesh Bakshi New York University
  • Nikhil Bansal University of Michigan
  • James Bartusek Columbia University
  • Raef Bassily Ohio State University
  • Paul Beame University of Washington
  • Avrim Blum Toyota Technological Institute at Chicago
  • Dan Boneh Stanford University
  • Simina Branzei Purdue University
  • Mark Braverman Princeton University
  • Clément Canonne The University of Sydney
  • Karthekeyan Chandrasekaran University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign
  • Moses Charikar Stanford University
  • Chandra Chekuri University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign
  • Sitan Chen Harvard University
  • Xi Chen Columbia University
  • Anindya De University of Pennsylvania
  • Tamal Dey Purdue University
  • Cynthia Dwork Harvard University
  • Alina Ene Boston University
  • Jeff Erickson University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign
  • Tony Feng University of California Berkeley
  • Sanjam Garg University of California Berkeley
  • Sumegha Garg Rutgers University
  • Ashish Goel Stanford University
  • Michael Goodrich University of California Irvine
  • Daniel Grier University of California San Diego
  • Zeyu Guo Ohio State University
  • Venkatesan Guruswami University of California Berkeley
  • Prahladh Harsha TIFR
  • Pooya Hatami Ohio State University
  • Samuel B. Hopkins MIT
  • Daniel Hsu Columbia University
  • Thore Husfeldt IT University of Copenhagen
  • Sandy Irani University of California Irvine
  • Aayush Jain Carnegie Mellon University
  • Bart M. P. Jansen Eindhoven University of Technology
  • Sanjeev Khanna New York University
  • Samir Khuller Northwestern University
  • Dakshita Khurana University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign
  • Isaac Kim University of California Davis
  • Pravesh K Kothari Princeton University
  • Robert Krauthgamer Weizmann Institute of Science
  • William Kretschmer University of Texas at Austin
  • Zeph Landau University of California Berkeley
  • François Le Gall Nagoya University
  • Felix Leditzky University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign
  • Chin Ho Lee North Carolina State University
  • Qipeng Liu University of California San Diego
  • Shachar Lovett University of California San Diego
  • Konstantin Makarychev Northwestern University
  • Yury Makarychev Toyota Technological Institute at Chicago
  • Giulio Malavolta Bocconi University
  • Tal Malkin Columbia University
  • Ruta Mehta University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign
  • Raghu Meka University of California Los Angeles
  • Tony Metger New York University
  • Peihan Miao Brown University
  • Sidhanth Mohanty Northwestern University
  • Shay Moran Technion
  • Elchanan Mossel MIT
  • Moni Naor Weizmann Institute of Science
  • Seffi Naor Technion
  • Anand Natarajan MIT
  • Jelani Nelson University of California Berkeley
  • Huy Le Nguyen Northeastern University
  • Chinmay Nirkhe University of Washington
  • Ryan O'Donnell Carnegie Mellon University
  • Shayan Oveis Gharan University of Washington
  • Prasad Raghavendra University of California Berkeley
  • Bhaskar Ray Chaudhury University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign
  • Lev Reyzin University of Illinois Chicago
  • Tim Roughgarden Institute for Advanced Study
  • Alexander Russell University of Connecticut
  • Amin Saberi Stanford University
  • Barna Saha University of California San Diego
  • Amit Sahai University of California Los Angeles
  • Anant Sahai University of California Berkeley
  • Tselil Schramm Stanford University
  • Rocco Servedio Columbia University
  • Alistair Sinclair University of California Berkeley
  • Makrand Sinha University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign
  • Nikhil Srivastava University of California Berkeley
  • Clifford Stein Columbia University
  • Madhu Sudan Harvard University
  • Avishay Tal University of California Berkeley
  • Li-Yang Tan Stanford University
  • Ewin Tang Princeton University
  • Eva Tardos Cornell University
  • Harsha Srimath Tirumala University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign
  • Salil Vadhan Harvard University
  • Thomas Vidick EPFL
  • Aravindan Vijayaraghavan Northwestern University
  • Ellen Vitercik Stanford University
  • Emmanouil-Vasileios Vlatakis-Gkaragkounis University of Wisconsin Madison
  • Jan Vondrak Stanford University
  • Thuy-Duong (June) Vuong University of California San Diego
  • Ryan Williams MIT
  • Ronald de Wolf University of Amsterdam
  • David Woodruff Carnegie Mellon University
  • Mihalis Yannakakis Columbia University
  • Henry Yuen Columbia University
  • Ruizhe Zhang Purdue University
  • David Zuckerman University of Texas at Austin
  • Uri Zwick Tel Aviv University